(Leaving) Black Shack Alley

Hello everyone, welcome back to my blog. The book for this week is Black Sheep Alley by Joseph Zobel. The book tells the coming-of-age tale of the author José, a young boy growing up on the island of Martinique, an overseas region of france and former colony. I really enjoyed the read, and found it to be very emotionally moving, especially knowing the story was based on real events. I also felt it touched on many important social topics such as the power of education, racial injustice, the cycle of poverty, and family sacrifice.

The first part of the book takes place in Black Shack Alley, a strip of ramshackle huts built on a sugar cane plantation, where José lives with his grandmother, M’man Tine. On most days the adults go off to work on the plantation and José and his friends are left alone in the alley with complete freedom. The children’s carefree existence and innocence at this time is in stark contrast to the harsh realities of the work on the plantation, where the adults sacrifice their bodies each day to earn paltry wages. In their naivety, they look at adult life on the plantation with a sense of curiosity, rather than the dread that it perhaps deserves. Plantation life is all the children have known so it just seems normal to them at the time, but as José grows up and later moves off of the plantation, he becomes increasingly aware of the brutal nature of his grandmother’s work.

José’s relationship with his grandmother was a very inspiring part of this book for me. In the absence of his true mother who is away working in another town, M’man Tine serves as a stern yet loving mother figure in José’s life. Despite the trouble he causes her, she is devoted to getting him away from the plantation so that he can receive an education. She sees education as a form of liberation, and as a way out of the cycle of poverty that the workers of the plantation are trapped in. Throughout the later years of her life, M’man Tine sacrifices everything, including her own health in order to give José the opportunity to live a better life. Sadly, José is not able to pay her back while she is alive, as she dies while he is still in school, but this book that he wrote serves as a tribute to her life.

Discussion question: How did knowing the book was based on the Author’s own life affect your experience reading it?

5 responses to “(Leaving) Black Shack Alley”

  1. I loved your post! The maternal relationship between José and M’man Tine was also one that stuck out to me greatly as one of the more impactful aspects of the book. To answer your question, once knowing that this story is semi-autobiographical, my reading of it definitely became more empathetic and the story felt more personal and real. It was both easier and harder to imagine the story as I read (easier because I knew it took place in reality, and harder because it was so devastating to read about such hardships while knowing they were real).

    Like

  2. Undoubtedly, M’man Tine was the reason Jo was able to get an education. If it weren’t for her, he might have been stuck on the plantation for good. Knowing this was a real woman who ran herself in the ground for her grandchild changed how I read this story. While sacrifice inevitably happens in family, not everyone would go to the same extent.

    Like

  3. Shanelle Danimae Cuevas Avatar
    Shanelle Danimae Cuevas

    I absolutely loved your post. I do agree that without M’mam Tine, José wouldn’t be where he is now and that’s honestly so inspiring. To answer your question, knowing it was autobiographical really did change the experience because it makes the contents of the story reality. It is something that has happened and just hearing it in the way Zobel writes it makes it both sad but inspiring.

    ~Shanelle

    Like

  4. “In their naivety, they look at adult life on the plantation with a sense of curiosity, rather than the dread that it perhaps deserves.”

    Yes, though I think that this ambivalence is also part of the book as a whole: Zobel is aware that the conditions in which people have to live and work in Black Shack Alley are awful and inhumane. On the other hand, he wants to hold on to and even celebrate some part of that experience: the sense of community, for instance, and the knowledge and resilience among the plantation workers.

    Like

  5. When I realize that this novel is based on his own true story, I will feel more empathy and empathy. At the same time, I ask myself: if all this suffering and oppression happened to me, would I still be able to be as strong as the main character and break the chains of fate?

    Like

Leave a comment

Design a site like this with WordPress.com
Get started